Best Marshmallows by Ellis Brooklyn Alternatives & Similar Perfumes
Marshmallows by Ellis Brooklyn is a citrus gourmand fragrance blending the sweetness of marshmallow and caramel with bright lemon and soft peach. It balances warm vanilla, musk, benzoin, and patchouli for a creamy yet fresh composition. Those drawn to this scent should look for perfumes combining gourmand notes with a citrusy lift and subtle musk to capture its playful yet comforting character.
Divin Enfant by Etat Libre d'Orange £155.00
- Key notes:
- marshmallow
- musk
- orange blossom
- Aromagroups:
- floral
"A child can either charm or annoy us with the same ruthlessness. A child can be irresistible with his angel-sweet smile but he also knows how to drive us crazy. Under the angel, the faked innocence of a demon.
After the gentle top notes of orange blossom and marshmallow, breaks the unexpected accord of coffee, leather and cold tobacco, a shrilling symbol of our sleepless nights. True to his reputation of “polymorphic pervert”, this mini-sized tyrant is only happy when he succeeds in imposing his whims, which he always manages to do.
What a sweet little monster!"
Lignum Vitae by Beaufort £125.00
- Key notes:
- amber
- caramel
- gaiac / guaiac wood
- ginger
- lemon
- oud
- sea salt
- vanilla
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- woody
Inspired by the innovative use of materials that allowed 18th century clockmakers to construct the first truly accurate marine chronometers, Lignum Vitae combines elements of wood, metal and salt to produce a truly unique, transportive fragrance. Lignum vitae itself is an incredibly dense wood - the only wood which is guaranteed to sink in water - which is indigenous to the Caribbean and the north coast of South America. The brand’s nautical theme is enhanced wonderfully by caramel, a madeleine cake accord and a cool winter lemon note which provide a truly unique gourmand experience akin to smelling warm shortbread, muffins or cupcakes.
In combining unexpected and exotic raw materials, Beaufort London celebrates the innovative spirit which brought to an end the search for lost time, and permitted the safe passage of ships across the world.
***
The Sniff on Lignum Vitae:
"An innovative gourmand fragrance with a masculine slant, Lignum Vitae by Beaufort London is something rather unexpected. And who doesn’t love a plot twist?"
402 Guilty Vanilla by Bon Parfumeur £60.00
- Key notes:
- benzoin
- caramel
- fig
- freesia
- sandalwood
- vanilla
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- woody
A sweet, ambery perfume with many shades of sweet packed into a single formula: heliotrope, vanilla, caramel, toffee and benzoin, all interlinked with a soft sandalwood theme.
Bon Parfumeur open olfactive dimensions and invite you to add your own story. Try 402 if you like sophisticated gourmands.
Perfumer for 402: Corinne Cachen.
Ambré Lumière 2023 by Molinard £145.00
- Key notes:
- amber
- benzoin
- lemon
- patchouli
- tolu balm
- ylang-ylang
- Aromagroups:
- vintage/old school
- woody
"This is Molinard’s 2023 re-issue of their iconic amber fragrance. This new format includes 90ml spray bottle and a 7.5ml roll-on.
Ambre Lumiere is retro amber with a hint of a patisserie counter deliciousness. This curious nuance comes from tolu which brings it's unique roast coffee aroma to the composition. This is combined with a special variety of chocolaty patchouli, sweet vanillic benzoin and creamy honeyed ylang-ylang."
Milk | Balanced & Expressive by Commodity £135.00
- Key notes:
- incense
- marshmallow
- milk accord
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- woody
Seeking comfort in the familiar, this creamy and calming scent offers the perfect haven. Cold milk adds a cooling element to an otherwise rich and warm fragrance of marshmallow, mahogany and tonka bean.
This is the Balanced & Expressive version of Milk, with a noticeable projection that’ll make a mark, not a scene. Also try Milk | Personal and Milk | Bold.
Milk | Bold by Commodity £135.00
- Key notes:
- incense
- marshmallow
- smoke
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- woody
Milk's warm notes of marshmallow, tonka bean and mahogany wood emblazoned with the unexpected smoky depth of firewood and amber. A smoky, sweet and inviting scent to be worn with confidence.
This is the Bold version of Milk, a powerful, room-filling rendition of its Balanced counterpart, infused with deep, dark notes that’ll make your presence known. Also try Milk | Personal and Milk | Balanced & Expressive
.
Milk | Personal by Commodity £135.00
- Key notes:
- cedarwood
- incense
- marshmallow
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- transparent
- woody
Milk's warm notes of marshmallow, tonka bean and mahogany wood are made lustrous with skin musk and white cedar. Light as a feather, this sweet and caressing scent lays close like a second skin. A creamy, sheer interpretation of Milk | Balanced & Expressive that is soft and innocent.
This is the Personal version of Milk, for those who prefer a subtle, intimately-projecting fragrance that invites closeness. Also try Milk | Balanced & Expressive and Milk | Bold.
Yes I do by Etat Libre d'Orange £155.00
- Key notes:
- jasmine
- lily-of-the-valley
- marshmallow
- Aromagroups:
- floral
Renamed for decency reasons, the perfume previously known as "Don`t Get Me Wrong Baby, I Don't Swallow" is now called "Yes, I do"
We are quoting ELdO here:
"It all starts with a hand on the nape of a neck. The hand of a man familiar with the practice of attracting young women, accustomed to crumpling their sleek hair and to getting the better of their well-behaved manners. This is the story of a man in a car at night, of a manly hand that draws a perfectly fresh face towards him - expressed at the start by a bouquet of white flowers: lily of the valley, jasmine and orange blossom–, and who anticipates the chocolaty taste and tenderness of a mouth. It is also the story of a woman who at first resists and finally goes down on him. The art of the “American kiss” unfurls on accords of ambre solaire, almond, sugar cane and marsh mallow. The man will discover everything there is to know about her: the warm roughness of her tongue, the rousing sensation of her back and forth. All there is to know and no more than that! The appetizer ends in a whisper: “Don’t get me wrong baby, I don’t swallow.”
***
Composition: Jasmine, lily of the valley, orange blossom, amber, patchouli, cacao, musk, marshmallow...
Perfumer: Antoine Maisondieu (who's also behind ELdO's Jasmin et Cigarette, Tom Ford's Velvet Orchid, quite a few Commes des Garcones, Burberry and many other perfumes)
Bergamask by Orto Parisi £155.00
- Key notes:
- lemon
- lilac
- lily-of-the-valley
- musk
- orange blossom
- white musk
- Aromagroups:
- citrusy
- floral
- woody
A rampage through a fantasy meadow. Lily-of-the-valley, orange blossom and lavender are crushed underfoot as you run riot across beauty. Lilac and lemon assert themselves in the carnage. Tonka bean and white musk ensures that this extrait strength perfume stays and plays.
Sunsuality by Pierre Guillaume White Collection £140.00
- Key notes:
- kumquat
- lemon
- musk
- sandalwood
- Aromagroups:
- citrusy
- woody
Silky citrus.
A particularly silky fragrance, where Pierre Guillaume transforms citrus acidity into a scented caress.
The kumquat-sandalwood accord seems infused with sunlight and bestows on the skin the charms of a melting creaminess, soft and fresh.
***
The Sniff on Sunsuality:
"[it] opens with a delicate white floral note, bolstered with a smooth citrus undertone. It doesn’t really matter if it is lemon blossom, or lemon and blossoms, either way the scent opens light, breezy, and expansive. It’s a transparent scent that conjures up images of white muslin curtains billowing in a Mediterranean breeze, all gauzy and floaty. The floral nuances are sweet, delicate, almost naive, whilst the lemon is sharper, sourer but never very aggressive."
About Marshmallows by Ellis Brooklyn
- How does Marshmallows by Ellis Brooklyn differ from these similar fragrances?
- Marshmallows uniquely balances citrus freshness with a sweet marshmallow and caramel gourmand core, enhanced by vanilla, musk, benzoin, and patchouli. Many similar fragrances focus more on floral, smoky, or woody facets, or emphasise specific notes like incense or amber, resulting in different overall characters.
- Which note in Marshmallows gives it the characteristic gourmand sweetness?
- The marshmallow note is central to the gourmand sweetness, supported by caramel and vanilla. These combine to create the creamy, sugary aspect that defines the fragrance’s warm appeal.
- Are these fragrances suitable for both day and evening wear like Marshmallows?
- Most fragrances listed blend fresh and sweet elements suitable for versatile wear. However, those with stronger smoky, woody, or amber notes may lean more towards evening use, while those with lighter citrus or floral touches can be appropriate for daytime.









